| No. | Result | Record | Opponent | Type | Round, time | Date | Location | Notes |
|---|
| 64 | Loss | 55–6–3 | Dick Tiger | RTD | 7 (15), 3:00 | Aug 10, 1963 | Liberty Stadium, Ibadan, Nigeria | For WBA and The Ring middleweight titles; For inaugural WBC middleweight title |
| 63 | Draw | 55–5–3 | Dick Tiger | SD | 15 | Feb 23, 1963 | Convention Center, Las Vegas, Nevada, US | For WBA and NSYAC middleweight titles |
| 62 | Loss | 55–5–2 | Dick Tiger | UD | 15 | Oct 23, 1962 | Candlestick Park, San Francisco, California, US | Lost WBA middleweight title |
| 61 | Win | 55–4–2 | Benny Paret | KO | 10 (15), 2:30 | Dec 9, 1961 | Convention Center, Las Vegas, Nevada, US | Retained NBA middleweight title |
| 60 | Win | 54–4–2 | Florentino Fernández | SD | 15 | Aug 5, 1961 | Ogden Stadium, Ogden, Utah, US | Retained NBA middleweight title |
| 59 | Win | 53–4–2 | Sugar Ray Robinson | UD | 15 | Mar 4, 1961 | Convention Center, Las Vegas, Nevada, US | Retained NBA middleweight title |
| 58 | Draw | 52
|